top of page

Dear Lara: classical music’s uncomfortable reckoning

10 minutes ago
4 min read

Lara St John’s documentary investigates stories of musicians abused by their teachers, prompting important questions for everyone in classical music – including me



Image generated using ChatGPT
Image generated using ChatGPT

In a week when the Predator’s Invincibility Cloak fell away from UK media darling Russell Brand, it seemed timely if depressing to go to a screening of Lara St John’s Dear Lara last Wednesday in London. The film starts with the violinist recounting her own sexual abuse by her teacher Jascha Brodsky as a 14-year-old student at Curtis Institute, which she made public in a Philadelphia Inquirer article in 2019. In response to the torrent of ‘Dear Lara’ messages she received from fellow survivors, she learnt to use a video camera and travelled across North America and Europe to interview these people and tell their stories.


The people she talks to are brave and frank, and she elicits gripping interviews, but the details are sickening and staggering. The casual entitlement these men had to the bodies of the young students in their care is repulsive. The psychological pressure they applied to the impressionable minds of youngsters starting out on their careers – often far away from their families – is unforgivable.


Also infuriating are the responses of the establishments involved, both in their handling of reports and their due diligence when hiring professors in the first place. In one case, a simple reference check by the HR department could have protected their students. When abuse is reported, boards and administrators obfuscate and bully.


Many of the names and cases were familiar to me. It is to my regret that in eight years as Editor of The Strad, I wasn’t able to investigate or report on any of the individual cases (I did write this opinion piece in 2012). I was aware of rumours from my own days as a student, but didn’t have the courage to investigate, nor did the magazine have the financial or legal resources to support such intensive work. I’m embarrassed that I commissioned Stephen Shipps to write an opinion piece for the magazine: he was subsequently sentenced to five years in federal prison. This leaves me with even more respect for journalists such as Helen Pidd and Anne Midgette for their forensic investigations, and for their respective publishers in supporting that work.


It would be nice to think that everything has changed since St John’s own experience in the 1980s. The response to last week’s news – both the outpouring of women telling their own stories of abuse or misogyny, and the inevitable backlash – demonstrate that the world itself hasn’t changed much. In music education, there are rules and safeguards in place now, but as her film shows, the issue is still live. Even recently, I’ve had conversations with young musicians who can run through a list of ‘dodgy’ teachers. I’m pretty sure that’s the case in any conservatoire anywhere in the world.


Maybe the conversations students have with each other are more open and informed than when I was a student, and serve to protect them. Younger generations talk about ‘allyship’. There are social media accounts that sail pretty close to the wind in sharing alleged abuse. Until these stories are properly investigated, though, they remain allegations. Systems are still undoubtedly weighted against those who speak up, but there is a risk of swinging too far in the other direction, taking away people’s livelihoods on the basis of unsubstantiated hearsay. Some of these situations are complex and specific. However, where there is smoke, someone should at least go over and check if there’s a fire.


Where do we go from here? I certainly don’t envy any editor who needs to make decisions about promoting a professor, or even an artist. Due diligence is essential, but where should the line be drawn? Being predatory, sleazy or controlling isn’t necessarily illegal, and I suspect the classical music world would be severely depleted if all such people were excluded. (And I don’t exonerate women from this charge – where there’s power there is often bad behaviour, regardless of gender.) We can at least expect that legal statutes serve as a minimum standard. But even then, what happens when these men come out of prison? As the film shows, some of them seem to be re-absorbed surprisingly easily.


When it comes to teaching, there are workarounds. Professors may be banned from teaching at home – this doesn’t necessarily solve the problem, though it can make life a lot harder for older and less mobile teachers. Studios are built with large windows – does that really stop the psychological aspects of abuse, or after-hours risk? Even online teaching can be exploited. Teachers ask students for permission to touch them, which is basic respect on one level, but bureaucratic on another. After all, sometimes the quickest way to fix someone’s posture or instrument hold is just to move it directly.


Perhaps the most constructive practice is that of group lessons, which have multiple benefits, including that those listening learn from their peers without the stress of the spotlight. But even that might not stop teachers doing things in plain sight. The fact remains that people who get off on transgressing boundaries will always try to transgress boundaries. Maybe the only thing that can stop them is fear of being held accountable. That incentive doesn’t seem effective enough at the moment, but maybe this film will start to change that.


There are currently no further showings of Dear Lara scheduled in the UK, but it’s already winning awards and I hope it will find the momentum needed to be shown widely. It puts the matter in plain sight and opens up important conversations. It might even forewarn young musicians. Sadly, the lessons they learn might be dispiriting: trust no one and don’t expect protection from your institution. The lesson I hope institutions do not take is that if you lawyer up, you’ll be okay. I return to what I wrote in 2012: ‘Ultimately in any organisation the buck stops at the top. The person in that position has the chance to set the organisational culture by making clear what unacceptable behaviour is, and providing clear, fair procedures for people who feel that they have a grievance. Above all, they have to listen to people in their charge, rather than just the ones with perceived power.’



©2022 by Elbow Music

bottom of page